By Emeritus Professor Harold Goodwin
One of the problems with certification is that they don’t carry meaning, they are opaque and there are so many of them. Travalyst lists 49 certification schemes as compliant with its criteria. Travalyst’s criteria are process driven; third party on-site and/or remote online assessment; schemes based on publicly available standards, focused on evaluating the impact of social and/or economic, and/or environmental factors. The certification process says nothing about what has been achieved, or what the consumer will experience.
How can the tourist make an informed choice between properties which are certified? In a drought, which hotel is using the least water per bed night? Which has the best labour practices? Which offers an authentic experience of the place?
As a consumer there are dimensions of “sustainability” which matter more to me than others. I doubt that I am different from most in this regard, Tourism businesses and destinations can seek to attract particular kinds of clients by describing what they are taking responsibly for and why and reporting the impact of their efforts. Sustainability has market value only when it connects meaningful with the tourist.
I have lost count of the number of times I have taken care to rehang my towel only to have it replaced with a new towel. When it happens in a certified hotel it undermines the certificate too. We hear a great deal about the intention-behaviour gap in consumer behaviour. We hear much less about the intention-action gap in corporate sustainability.
The consumer who finds that the hotel fails to deliver on sustainability has little chance of securing redress, the guest cannot find out what the hotel has been certified for and has no contract with certifying agency from which they might seek compensation.
Certification is perhaps best seen as a “hygiene” assurance for those businesses concerned about their supply chain, particularly tour operators. Businesses in destinations are very vulnerable to source market businesses demanding certification, the more so if different operators demand different certificates.
Booking.com has reported a steady increase in accommodations displaying a third-party certification, growing from 18,000 in 2024 to over 26,000 in 2025. Estimates of the number of hotels in the world suggest there are around 187,000. Very few are certified.
Booking.com suggests that third-party sustainability certification could help hotels to attract more business travellers. Corporate travel demand partners “observed a notable increase in the percentage of As Booked Room Nights (ABRN) at properties with a certification displayed, growing from 13% in November 2024 to 24.5% in September 2025.” They then repeated the research with a second partner. “Since accessing certification data in 2025, their share of ABRN at certified accommodations increased from 17.26% to 21%.”
Research by Professor Xavier Font has revealed some issues around certification
Eva Martin Fuentes, Juan Pedro Mellinas, Cèsar Fernández, and Xavier Font analysed 6,696 hotels across the world’s top 100 city destinations, matching Expedia’s customer-submitted eco-friendliness ratings with Booking.com’s sustainability data (self-reported practices and third-party certifications).
They found that: “eco” ratings reflect how much guests liked their stay, not how sustainable the hotel is. For industry, this means that certification and self-reporting currently have little effect on perceptions or satisfaction; they support compliance more than marketing.”
They concluded that: “To close the perception gap, hotels and platforms must integrate visible, guest-relevant sustainability actions into the experience and communication flow, rather than relying on badges or back-of-house practices alone.”
Businesses and destinations need to explain what they are and why they chose to address those issues. To avoid being accused of misselling they need robust evidence to support their claims. Having a certificate does not enable a business or destination to make specific claims which they cannot substantiate – misselling regulations apply.
To ready more about misselling regulations check out this post What’s happening to the Green Claims Directive?
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
You may hear that I have long been opposed to certication. This was published on the WTM Global Hub May 31 2017 Certification:what comes next?
The purpose of consumer facing certification is presumably to assure the guest or client that the hotel they are planning to stay in, or the operator they plan to travel through, meets a given sustainability standard. But there are problems:
Greenwashing
Each time a traveller or holidaymaker checks into a certified hotel and goes to the room to find the thermostat set at 15C, all the lights and the TV on, and a bit of card stuck in the key card light switch, more damage is done to certification. When you turn the thermostat up or off, switch off all the lights and the TV, and put the towels back on the rail as you leave in the morning only to find, on returning to your room, the aircon back on, a freezing room with lights blazing and fresh towels, consumer confidence in certification is undermined.
The consumer has no effective redress. The hotel does not award itself the certificate and makes no particular sustainability claim. The consumer has no contractual relationship with the certification agency. The consumer has been miss-sold but has no redress.
Rahman, Park & Chi of Washington State University have published a paper in the Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management on the Consequences of ‘Greenwashing:’ Consumers’ Reactions to Hotels’ Green Initiatives, concluding that “hotels need to be watchful so that consumers do not become sceptical. Therefore, it is of utmost importance that managers do everything possible to give customers no room for doubt.”
The A card imploring clients to save the planet by not having their towels washed every day juxtaposed to plastic bottles of shampoo, the air conditioning down at 15C and it taking 5 minutes for the shower to run warm , speak loudly of the hotel management’s real motivation. It undermines the hotel’s green credentials revealing that it is just about cost saving. When it happens in a certified hotel it undermines the certificate too.
“I can count on half of one hand the number of hotels that have actually paid attention to the location of my towel. I’ve seen countless housekeepers dump the contents of in-room recycling bins into their trash bags. I don’t have any expectations at motels, but when it comes to boutique, “eco-friendly”, or high-end properties making these claims, I find it infuriating.” Laurel Miller goes on to provide a checklist to help identify those hotels which are not greenwashing: How to tell if a hotel is greenwashing. I share Laurel Miller’s experience. Rarely are the towels I put back on the rack there after the housekeepers have been in.
Consumers have long been sceptical of carbon offsets, the cheat neutral video explains why – if you haven’t watched it, watch it now. It will make you smile. Now the EU has published a review of carbon offsets, 85% of the offset projects used by the EU under the UN’s Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) failed to reduce emissions.
More and more consumers have some environmental knowledge, from their education and their experience, many have fitted eco shower heads at home, they’ve thought about solar. They can spot the brown stuff behind the green labels. Rarely do we see hotels or operators making false or exaggerated claims – they know that what they say is contractual and that there can be penalties for misrepresentation.
As Justin Francis has pointed out: “When you buy organic certified food you know no pesticides have been used. When you buy Fair Trade coffee you know the farmer has been paid a little extra. When you book a sustainable tourism-certified hotel under existing schemes, you don’t know whether they use a ‘reasonable’ or ‘sustainable’ amount of water or energy; in fact figures are rarely even made available.”
What could be done?
Certificates are awarded for effort rather than achievement. I am less concerned about how a hotel reduces its energy consumption per bed night than that it reduces the consumption. Wouldn’t it be amazing if certificates were awarded for achieving an acceptable level of water and energy consumption per bed night, for paying wages above minimum wage levels and meeting a minimum set of labour standards.
Responsible Tourism encourages stakeholders to address the issues which matter locally, to address local priorities – water consumption matters more in some places than in others. Standards need to recognise the local priorities, global standards can’t do that.
The international Blue Flag label rightly describes itself as “a world-renowned eco-label trusted by millions around the globe.” It is because the consumer knows what standard the beach management delivers. The certificate has real meaning.
Wouldn’t it been even more amazing if hotels and operators published their operational performance against the standard, and the certifiers audited that performance and signed off on the evidence; thereby taking real responsibility for their certificates. Metered electricity consumption would quickly reveal the real performance of the hotel – and whether or not the room key light switches were being overridden. We need to know what the business has achieved that makes them worthy of the certification and we need to know how they compare with others. Then when travelling to a water scarce region I could choose to stay in one of the hotels with the lowest water usage per bed night or the one with the best employment conditions. Then certification would carry real meaning.
It would be even more amazing if the auditors could be held to account for their technical skills and their integrity.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License